I like having my Nextcloud apps tested automatically both locally and on continuous interation build services like Travis CI. While those automated tests will never cover 100% of the code base, they give me some level of confidence that a changeset does not break any features.
Testing is a complex topic with various aspects. I like the idea of the test pyramid that categorizes tests into three categories:
- Unit tests are the foundation of automated tests. They ensure that each component (e.g. class or function) works in isolation. The subject under test is not allowed to talk to any other components. Instead, they are mocked to ensure isolation and prevent side effects.
- System tests or integration tests ensure components also work when put together. These tests are allowed to talk to other components and external systems like databases.
- UI tests are the most complex tests as these test all layers of the software. For Nextcloud apps that have a user interface this means clicking around in the web interface.
Writing Test Cases
The Nextcloud server repository offers a versatile base class for automated
test cases, the
\Test\Testcase class. This class is recommended by the
development manual. While this class offers a lot of great advantages,
I don’t use it in my apps because of the following reasons.
I want to test often, ideally after every change in either my source or test code. If tests are slow, you tend to execute them rarely or maybe event don’t run them locally at all. If you’re lucky all tests pass on CI on your first push. But in many cases, you break a test case you didn’t even consider relevant for you changes. And having to wait for the CI system to pick up your pull request’s builds may take a few minutes during working ours and you’ll do other work inbetween, loosing focus on your current task.
Thus, I like to have fast tests. Especially unit tests should be fast as they run in isolation and thus don’t need any preparation/cleanup steps that otherwise tend to come with a certain overhead.
Unexpected Side Effects
If you’ve ever tried to just run any tests that are based on the server test case than you’ve probably noticed that your test instance is borked. It took me a while to figure that out but it has to do with the cleanup steps taken in the base class which seem to be too agressive for my use cases. The class is meant to be run via the provided shell script which will create a separate data directory for your tests.
The apps I develop don’t really use any files and thus this extensive cleanup is unnecessary.
Writing my own Testing Framework
Since I haven’t been using the Nextcloud test case for a while and instead, used PHPUnit classes directly, I’ve started to write small abstractions of those classes for the Mail app and the TOTP two-factor auth app. For Mail I had developed integration tests that essentially were unit tests that ran in a database transaction to reset the instance after each test run to the state before the test ran. For the TOTP app I wrote my own test base class to run Selenium UI tests on Sauce Labs.
Then I realized that I could merge those two and create my own (micro) testing framework that is both fitting my needs and still generic enough to be used in other apps.
One class to rule them all
This micro framework consists of a single abstract base class and a few traits. The goal is to use the same base class for all tests and depending on which traits are included, specific tasks are executed before or after the test.
For unit tests,
TestCase doesn’t have any noticable overhead compared to
running tests purely on PHPUnit.
To run tests that aren’t isolated and thus produce side effects, I’ve created
DatabaseTransaction trait, that when included starts a transaction before
each test in the test class that is rolled back after each test execution. Not
only is it much easier to reset a database via a transaction than via manual
queries, it has shown to be a lot faster.
This concept was taken from the Laravel framework where integration tests are handled in a similar way.
The TOTP two-factor auth app is UI tested based on Selenium and Sauce
Labs. When the
Selenium trait is used, a
WebDriver instance can be
$this->webDriver - ready to execute any actions on the web
interface. The configuration (credentials for SL) is read from environment
variables so that it works both locally and on CI where the password is
encryted and injected via the environment.
There are a few aspects I dislike on the default test base class provided by the Nextcloud server, so I’ve created my own micro testing framework. It’s simple, fast and flexible and allows to write unit, integration and UI tests.
If you’d like to give this framework a try, you can install it via composer:
composer install --save-dev christophwurst/nextcloud_testing